The Problem with Worthwhile Causes



There are just so many of them. There are so many ideals that a person can aspire to. A building can be healthy, smart, sustainable, innovative, appealing, beautiful, empowering, feasible, economic, green, simple, structurally sound, made from stock parts, built by hand, allowed to adapt, breathable, socially transparent, shocking, inclusive, recycled, net zero, cheap, an icon, and the list could continue until we have run out of words. We talk about these things like we can accomplish them all if we just try hard enough. I don’t think we can. Yes, building with product that have no negative impact on the environment is worthy. Yes, allowing the design process to include clients or other disciplines is worthy. Yes, designing a project after embedding yourself in a culture for years is worthy. Yes, designing with monetary impact in mind is worthy. 

We are told that all of these things are good, but as soon as we choose one good thing to include, there is a consequence. Take for example our current studio project. Amy and I have developed a scheme with a plethora of exterior spaces. A classroom can be expanded to include this outside spaces. This creates both a pleasant and healthy connection to the world plus it allows us to utilize passive cooling strategies to decrease our energy usage. But anyone with allergies will not succeed in these beautiful spaces.  

I am at a loss. I don’t know how to figure out which thing is my thing. I don’t know which thing I will hold as most worthy. I don’t know what things are pushed to lower rungs of usefulness or attention. 


Comments

  1. I totally see your point of view on this, and share it at as well. It is hard for us to really integrate all GREAT ideas and have them work cohesively. It seems like there is always a trade-off even for the good ones. We see in the STARchitecture we see today. Every great building we study has things that were problems with the project, and this is something we will continue to experience. I guess it's just a matter of prioritization and what truly matters in the projects we do. Each project, no matter what firm we work at, the types of projects we do, the type of client we have, will have this negotiation that we will have to work with. I think this is where the magic of the design can be made and great things can come; when we prioritize and focus instead of trying to solve all of the worlds problems within one realm.

    ReplyDelete
  2. That is a very difficult question but in the end all that can truly be done is for the designer to do the best design they are capable of.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts