For the "Little Boxes"


Margaret Crawfords text, Little Boxes, was quite refreshing to read, as it was an argument for the sprawling, suburban landscapes that so many people detest for fear of mass conformity, collapse of the individual, and the status quo. While I am a skeptic to the idea of cookie-cutter houses that all look identical on a block, I do not believe that this is any indication of a negative impact on society. While suburban communities are less dense, they are not necessarily less diverse as they as they attract middle class, working class, poor, white, black, Hispanic, and Pilipino alike. Historically speaking, these tract houses attracted diversity because they were affordable, giving more people access to what was considered the American Dream at the time. These homes, contrary to a rented unit in the urban context, were flexible; people could adapt them to their individual needs, for growth and change. Margaret Crawford points out that some of the brightest and most innovative individuals have come from these sprawling communities, so they cannot be all bad. I think it is important to put the arguments against suburban landscapes in perspective: both urban and suburban have their positives and negatives, so I am not sure that we can say one is better than the other. Each have a way of supporting strong, healthy, and resilient communities.




Comments

  1. Yes, it is hard to choose one from two. The city problem is too complex that each city has a different situation. The small house is one kind of "dream" here. But in China the house is much more expensive, the city is cheaper.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think that the issue with these types of communities is that it is very easy to begin to conform to a norm by virtue of everyone's properties starting to blend together. The idea that everyone exists in a visually similar setting can easily enable children growing up that their house or their property should match that of Billy Bob's. This comparison can be unhealthy, but obviously exists in all other locations, too. So, tricky one.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts