Sidewalks and Safety
I have always enjoyed reading Jane Jacobs because she not only observes the things that happen in the city but offers solutions to the problems she has seen. She turns something as simple as a sidewalk into conscious architectural practice. Her observations are also very spot on. For example, the sidewalk is a space that is policed by the public. The safest sidewalks are those that are walked regularly and provided a clear boundary between what is public and what is private.
This idea of the safe sidewalk might be common sense, but I bet if you were to ask the class about their experience of sidewalks, their response would be mixed. I am thinking of responses in terms of gender. If I had to guess, a majority of the males in our class have probably rarely come across unsafe sidewalks. But the females can probably think of at least one unsafe sidewalk they have recently walked. I know from my own experience that even the safest sidewalks can become unsafe once the sun has set. I can recall many times when I have been warned to keep my wits about me on a low-lit street.
I suppose what I am getting at is that user experience differs based on our experiences and the demographics we fall under. There are certain aspects of design that get overlooked because we are not immediately affected by the implications of our designs. Something as simple as a sidewalk can be designed so that all users feel safe in the space. If we take some time to put ourselves in others' shoes, we can become better designers.

I love how Clemson's solution to unsafe sidewalks has been to slap the emergency buttons in dark parts of campus. I certainly don't want to be walking to my car at night if it's parked in the commuter lots. It's empty and dark - but thank god there's an emergency button. Unless I'm being chased by a zombie, I'm probably not going to avoid any immediate threats. There is Tiger Transit, and you can call and ask for a lift at night, but I wish we all had the ability to enjoy our own agency and walk on campus.
ReplyDeleteGod forbid I walk down the sidewalk during the day and get catcalled. But society isn't ready to have that conversation because "I should take it as a compliment" and "boys will be boys"
DeleteThe safe sidewalk can and should be used in all aspects of design. What is suitable for some is not suitable for others. This also relates to urbanization and gentrification, not just in terms of safety. Yes, flattening a run-down neighborhood looks better for the city and a lot of people living in it, but where will those inhabitants go? Like you said, if we, as designers, consider everyone as best we can, the world would be a better place. This opens up the conversation of equity vs. equality.
ReplyDeleteGotta agree with Colin, and you of course Taylor. Our solution to making the area safe is to put up some emergency buttons and have police patrol. But it's like Jacobs said, "No amount
ReplyDeleteof police can enforce civilization where the normal, casual enforcement of it has broken down." I don't know the best solution because I think a large part of why we feel so unsafe in a lot of places is that we have no real sense of community. I don't know that many people besides the Trump loving rednecks who love this country so much they're willing to burn it down that feel a sense of deep community. We live in temporary communities of strangers, and American society teaches a discord where you look out for you and no one else. Sadly, I think this is part of the problem that architecture can't fully solve. But I could be wrong.