The Process
In John Harbraken's article, Questions That Will Not Go Away, he states,
"A good method allows each of us to do
our own with a minimum of fuss"
and then
"Indeed, in architectural design as in music, method allows
coordination, but thereby also stimulates improvisation"
It gave me a space to think about architecture, or music, or really any art form
that requires a method or process to make.
In these three years of studying architecture, I have found out that it really
is the most important factor for success.
I have done other artful things like learning to play the guitar or leathework,
and everytime I notice that once I have a method, or formula down, then and
only then, can I deviate and 'riff' or 'improv'.
It's really through this foundational process structure, that I am allowed
to create more things.
Harbraken also states,
"What is common cannot be special, but it can be
of high quality"
This quote in particular builds upon this idea of process.
Do we need to re-invent the wheel from the beginning in this field?
Should we allow ourselves to be common, and build that foundation so
that we can deviate later on?
If architecture were instead a musical instrument, we would learn how to play
scales, chords and maybe a song before we wrote our own things.
I think natural ability and talent exist, but without structure of some kind, how
far can it develop?
Ian - I also really loved the analogy to music in terms of a method that allows for creative expression to then find its voice. I think it's really true for architecture, the need for some kind of structure that allows us all to exist in, and I think it's an opportunity for beauty rather than merely a prohibitive restraint like many people might assume.
ReplyDeleteIan, as a singer I completely understand where the correlation between music and architecture comes from. I too have spoken on this relationship in previous semesters and I have always said, music speaks in one voice. If you ever hear an English person sing and an American sing, you can't tell the difference because the voice comes out the same. The same as it seems with architecture, however I don't think we have found our one voice yet. We have yet to find the foundational unison.
ReplyDeleteI love how you compared architecture with other skills and hobbies; particularly music in this case, but also leatherwork. Even with baking, you learn the basic recipe first and as you become more comfortable, you can deviate and create something new or adjust the recipe a bit. And why not everyone will be the next famous singer or champion baker, it's a skill that cultivates culture and brings fun to the world.
ReplyDelete