What defines a buildings fate? Maybe Politics.
Last year i witnessed one of the most iconic building of my city being demolished due to politics. The Hall of Nations, .the world’s first and largest-span space-frame structure
built in reinforced concrete, holds special significance in India's post-colonial
history—it was inaugurated in 1972 to commemorate twenty-five years of the
young country’s independence. The demolition was part of a comprehensive redevelopment plan. The significant questions
that beg to be asked at this point is how in a city with several heritage
preservation agencies does a situation arise where the judiciary is left to make
calls on the fate of structures widely viewed as having heritage value? The
answer to the this question concerns my city’s messy bureaucratic machinery, there are as many as
nine agencies, including the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI), the
city’s municipal corporations, and INTACH, concerned with the protection of the
city’s notified built heritage—all with varying degrees of power and influence.
The largest power lies with the Heritage Conservation
Committee (HCC), which works under the Indian Government’s Ministry of Urban
Development. While defending its case in the High Court, it was disclosed that HCC had decided to only consider building older than 60 years old to be considered in the heritage list.The decision now
has left several other post-independence buildings in a legal vacuum of sorts
and vulnerable to being demolished. This entire saga is also believed to have
been driven by real estate concerns.
This is such a sad story Atika, thank you for sharing. It exposes a vulnerability within historical preservation, which may exist in other countries as well. A building does not have to be old to be considered valuable. This means they will have to work to change the metrics of what determines a building of value that requires protection.
ReplyDeleteThis is such a sad story Atika, thank you for sharing. It exposes a vulnerability within historical preservation, which may exist in other countries as well. A building does not have to be old to be considered valuable. This means they will have to work to change the metrics of what determines a building of value that requires protection.
ReplyDelete