Commodity, Leisure, and Why the West has a Big Problem
I often find it amusing listening to the two "big" sides in our society duking it out over which system is preferable. I speak of course of the discourse between Capitalism and Communism. Coming from a place of solidarity, I sympathize with much of the critique laid down upon the feet of our capitalist society. However, I think the problem is much deeper than bourgeois spending habits and can be seen in the landscape of our architecture. A society devoid of meaning, will never find fulfillment no matter how big the architecture produced.
In his work, On Leisure, Joseph Pieper comments, “the greatest menace to our capacity for contemplation is the incessant fabrication of tawdry empty stimuli which kill the receptivity of the soul.” The West has had a problem with leisure for quite sometime, and nothing illustrates this more than the mall, a cacophony of themed spaces designed to pass what little time we have as quickly as possible while at the same time draining our resources through commerce. In a culture devoid of meaning, all we have is physical “stuff” to pacify our lizard brains until we all walk out with a bang... Cinnabon-in-hand.
Big architecture attempts to fill this giant hole in our souls searching for the meaning our society robbed us of long ago. I end with this thought, “Our culture has filled our heads, but emptied our hearts, stuffed our wallets but starved our wonder. It has fed our thirst for facts but not for meaning or mystery. It produces “nice" people, not heroes.” - Peter Kreeft

Sean, I found your thoughts, and those of the authors you included really compelling when you remind us that architecture + design is and always has been a reflection of society at the time they were created.
ReplyDeleteThank you, Andrew! I totally agree.
DeleteSean I personally prefer Auntie Annes however your point is still valid. I liked your comment that "A society devoid of meaning, will never find fulfillment no matter how big the architecture produced." I think this ties into why you are so infatuated with the classical architecture. I can see where the lack luster, seemingly unpurposeful junkspace architecture gives no direction to people who often seek direction to find meaning.
ReplyDeleteAuntie Annes is a close second for me.
DeleteRight, I think architecture should orient individuals toward the good. It's not enough just to "shock". Like a drug, the high you get is real, but it is short lasting. You will need to introduce a larger and larger dose to pacify your craving until you either overdose or die from withdrawal. I'm not saying Classical Architecture is the only way to do this...but it was a good answer...and I don't think the answer we have now comes close to addressing the growing problem.
I love this line: In a culture devoid of meaning, all we have is physical “stuff” to pacify our lizard brains until we all walk out with a bang... Cinnabon-in-hand.
ReplyDeleteanonymous is me sorry
DeleteMe too haha
Delete